Measuring Success in a Zero-Click World: GEO Metrics & ROI
60% of Google searches now end without a click. For B2B marketers, this isn't just a trend—it's a fundamental shift in how success is measured.
Success in Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) is no longer defined by organic traffic or click-through rates. Instead, it's measured by Share of Model (SoM)—how often Large Language Models (LLMs) cite your brand as the answer. As search engines evolve into answer engines, the traditional funnel is collapsing. Users now consume information directly on the search results page or within the chat interface, forcing B2B marketers to rethink their measurement strategy from capturing clicks to securing influence.
The urgency for this shift is driven by the "Zero-Click" reality. In 2024, nearly 60% of all Google searches resulted in zero clicks to an external website, according to data from SparkToro and Intelligency Group. Furthermore, Gartner predicts that by 2028, organic search traffic for brands will decrease by 50% or more as consumers embrace generative AI-powered search. In this environment, a decline in website traffic doesn't necessarily signal a decline in brand relevance—as long as your brand is being recommended by the AI.
Why Traffic is the Wrong Metric for AI Search
Traffic metrics (Sessions, Users, CTR) are failing because they measure a behavior—clicking—that AI interfaces are actively designing out of the user journey. When an LLM like ChatGPT or Google's AI Overviews provides a comprehensive answer to a user's query, the user has no reason to click through to your website. They've already received the value.
If you continue to judge your content's performance solely by Google Analytics, you'll likely see a decline that looks like failure. However, if that same content was the source of the AI's answer, it successfully built brand authority and mental availability, even without a visit.
The "Invisible" Funnel of AI Search:
User asks: "What is the best CRM for enterprise sales?"
AI answers: "Salesforce and HubSpot are top choices due to..." (Citing your comparison guide)
User decision: "I'll look into HubSpot."
Attribution Gap: Your content drove the decision, but attribution becomes fragmented. The click might show as a referral from the AI tool, or the user might search "HubSpot" directly—making your content's influence invisible in traditional analytics.
Key Insight: In a zero-click world, the primary goal of content is not to drive a visit, but to influence the answer generated by the AI model.
What is Share of Model (SoM)?
So if traffic is the wrong metric, what should you measure instead?
Share of Model (SoM) is the GEO equivalent of Share of Voice (SoV). It quantifies the percentage of times your brand is mentioned, cited, or recommended by an LLM in response to category-relevant prompts. Unlike traditional SoV, which measures visibility in a list of links (SERP), SoM measures your presence in the synthesized answer.
High Share of Model means your brand is consistently part of the AI's "consideration set." This is critical because LLMs act as gatekeepers. If you're not in the training data or the retrieval set, you don't exist to the user.
Comparison: Share of Voice (SEO) vs. Share of Model (GEO)
What it measures
Ranking position in search results
Frequency of brand mentions in AI-generated answers
Primary goal
Get clicked
Get cited
Visibility format
Blue link on SERP
Text within the AI response
User action
Click to visit
Consume answer in-place
Attribution
Google Search Console
Manual audit or GEO tracking tools
The 3 Core GEO KPIs You Must Track
To effectively measure your GEO efforts, you must track metrics that reflect visibility within the AI's output.
1. Citation Frequency (The "Mention" Metric)
This measures how often your brand or content is cited as a source. In platforms like Perplexity or Google AI Overviews, this is often visible as a footnote or a "Learn more" link.
Metric: Number of citations per 100 category prompts
Goal: Be cited as the primary source for your core keywords
2. Brand Sentiment Score
Being mentioned isn't enough—context matters. Is the AI recommending you, comparing you neutrally, or highlighting a weakness?
Positive: "Brand X is the industry leader for..."
Neutral: "Brand X is also an option."
Negative: "Users often complain about Brand X's pricing."
Metric: % Positive vs. Neutral vs. Negative mentions
3. Category Dominance (The "Top List" Metric)
For "Best of" or "Top X" prompts, does your brand appear in the list? And if so, at what position?
Metric: Presence in the top 3 recommendations for high-intent "Best [Category]" prompts
Key Insight: Share of Model (SoM) measures the frequency and sentiment of a brand's appearance in LLM-generated responses, replacing rank position as the key indicator of success.
How to Measure GEO Performance: A Systematic Framework
Since Google Search Console doesn't yet provide "ChatGPT Impressions," you need to build your own measurement framework. Here's a systematic approach that industry leaders use to track GEO performance.
Step 1: Define Your "Golden Prompts"
Identify the 20-50 questions your target audience asks that should lead to your brand.
Informational: "How to automate B2B invoicing?"
Commercial: "Best invoicing software for small business"
Brand: "Is [Competitor] better than [Your Brand]?"
Step 2: The Manual Audit Matrix (Monthly)
Run these prompts through the major AI engines (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity) and record the results.
For each prompt, track:
Is your brand mentioned? (Yes/No)
Sentiment: Positive, Neutral, or Negative
Position: If in a list, what rank? (1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc.)
Citation type: Direct link, inline mention, or footnote
Create a simple tracking sheet with columns for each AI engine and rows for each Golden Prompt. Update monthly to identify trends.
Step 3: Utilize Emerging GEO Tools
While manual auditing is essential for qualitative insights, new tools are emerging to automate this process:
Semrush Enterprise AIO: Tracks share of voice in AI Overviews
Qwairy / Brandlight: Specialized tools for tracking brand mentions in LLMs
Perplexity Discover: Monitor if your content is trending or being used as a source in Perplexity's ecosystem
This methodology forms the foundation of how we built the Deca platform—designed to help teams track, optimize, and improve their Share of Model at scale.
Moving Forward: From Clicks to Citations
The shift to Zero-Click Search isn't the death of digital marketing—it's the evolution of it. By focusing on Share of Model and Citation Frequency, you align your strategy with the reality of how modern B2B buyers consume information. The battleground has shifted from clicks to answers.
Success in a zero-click world means ensuring that when an AI is asked about your industry, your brand is consistently part of the answer.
FAQs
1. How can I track traffic from ChatGPT if there are no clicks?
Track mentions first, traffic second. For AI tools that do link (like Perplexity or Bing Chat), check referral traffic in Google Analytics 4 (GA4) from domains like perplexity.ai, bing.com, or searchgpt.com. Your primary metric should be Share of Model—how often you're mentioned—not just visits.
2. What is the difference between Share of Voice and Share of Model?
Share of Voice (SoV) measures your share of search ranking positions—how much "shelf space" you occupy on Google. Share of Model (SoM) measures your share of the generated answer—how often an AI model explicitly recommends or cites your brand.
3. Can I use Google Search Console for GEO?
Yes, but with limitations. Google Search Console tracks clicks from Google's traditional search and increasingly from AI Overviews (which often appear in GSC data). However, GSC doesn't track visibility in ChatGPT, Claude, or other non-Google LLMs. You'll need additional tracking for those platforms.
4. What is a "Golden Prompt"?
A "Golden Prompt" is a high-value, bottom-of-funnel question that your ideal customer asks when they're ready to buy or deeply researching a solution (e.g., "Best enterprise accounting software for manufacturing"). Winning these prompts is the primary goal of GEO.
5. Why is "Sentiment" important in GEO?
Unlike a blue link, an AI answer carries tone and context. If an AI mentions your brand but says "it has a steep learning curve" or "is expensive," that mention can actually hurt conversion. Monitor sentiment to ensure you're not just visible, but recommended.
6. Is Zero-Click search really happening?
Yes. Data from 2024 shows that nearly 60% of Google searches end without a click. This trend is accelerating with the rollout of AI Overviews, which answer questions directly on the results page.
7. How do I improve my Share of Model?
Create "Citation-Ready" content: highly structured, fact-dense content that LLMs can easily parse and verify. Ensure your brand is mentioned in authoritative third-party sources (news, reviews, industry publications) that models use for training and retrieval. Focus on answering the specific questions your audience asks AI tools.
References
Last updated