Measuring Success: Beyond Traffic and Rankings
1. The Traffic Fallacy
For two decades, the "Click" was the currency of SEO. We optimized for CTR, session duration, and bounce rates. In the GEO era, these metrics are becoming dangerously misleading. With AI Overviews and chatbots answering queries directly, Zero-Click Searches have surpassed 60%.
If your dashboard shows declining organic traffic, but your revenue remains stable, you are likely winning in GEO but measuring it wrong. The user got the answer from your content via AI, trusted your brand, and converted later (or offline). We must pivot from measuring traffic to measuring influence.
2. The New North Star: Share of Model (SoM)
Just as "Share of Voice" measured market presence, Share of Model (SoM) measures your brand's presence in the neural networks of AI.
Key GEO Metrics to Track
Share of Model (SoM)
Percentage of times your brand is cited in AI answers for key category prompts.
Manual/Automated querying of Top 20 category questions in ChatGPT/Gemini/Perplexity.
Citation Frequency
How often your URL is linked as a source in AI Overviews.
Track referral traffic from "google / organic" with specific fragment parameters or via Search Console "AI Overview" filters (emerging).
Sentiment Score
The qualitative context of your mention (e.g., "Best for enterprise" vs "Cheap alternative").
NLP analysis of AI responses containing your brand name.
Entity Confidence
How clearly the Knowledge Graph understands your brand.
Google Knowledge Graph API Score.
3. The "Ghost Traffic" Phenomenon
Users reading your content inside an AI answer creates "Ghost Traffic"—value delivered without a site visit. To capture this value, you must correlate Brand Search Volume and Direct Traffic with your GEO efforts.
The Metric Shift:
Old: "How many people visited my blog post?"
New: "How many AI models cite my blog post as the definitive truth?"
4. Actionable Tracking Strategy
The "Top 50" Audit: Identify the top 50 questions your persona asks. Run them through ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini bi-weekly. Record if you are cited.
Correlation Analysis: Overlay your "Direct Traffic" graph with your "AI Optimization" timeline. A rise in direct navigation often signals successful GEO.
Referral Scrubbing: Watch for traffic from
perplexity.ai,bing.com(Chat), and other AI-first engines. These are high-intent visitors.
Conclusion
Stop panicking over traffic drops. If your Share of Model is rising, you are building the ultimate asset: Brand Authority. In the age of AI, being the source is more valuable than being the destination.
FAQ: Measuring GEO
Q: Are there tools to automate Share of Model tracking?A: The market is nascent. Tools like Authoritas, BrightEdge, and emerging GEO-specific SaaS are building these capabilities. Currently, manual sampling or custom Python scripts using LLM APIs are the most reliable methods.
Q: Does "Time on Page" still matter?A: Yes, but differently. High engagement signals to Google (via Chrome user data) that your content is high-quality, which feeds back into the ranking algorithms that feed the AI. It’s a quality signal, not just a conversion metric.
Q: What is a good "Share of Model" percentage?A: It depends on the competitive density. In niche B2B, aiming for 60%+ citation on core definition terms is realistic. In broad B2C, 20-30% is a dominant position.
Q: Can I track which specific text the AI quoted?A: Not directly through analytics yet. However, if you structure your content with unique "quotable blocks" (as per Draft 3), you can manually verify if those specific phrases appear in AI outputs.
References
Ayzenberg: The Evolution of Search and the Importance of Share of Model (https://www.ayzenberg.com/insights/the-evolution-of-search-and-the-importance-of-share-of-model-for-brands/)
Hallam Agency: Share of Model: A Key Metric for AI-Powered Search (https://hallam.agency/blog/share-of-model-a-key-metric-for-ai-powered-search/)
Addlly AI: How to Measure GEO Success (https://addlly.ai/blog/how-to-measure-geo-success/)
Last updated