How to Win the 'Us vs. Them' AI Comparison?

Defensive GEO is a risk management strategy designed to protect brand authority and influence comparative narratives within Generative AI outputs. According to a 2025 study by Concord, traditional organic results can lose up to 45% of traffic when AI Overviews are present, making inclusion in AI-generated "consideration sets" critical for survival. This guide covers actionable frameworks to control how AI models compare your brand against competitors.

---

Why AI Comparisons Are the New Battleground

AI comparisons are zero-sum scenarios where Large Language Models (LLMs) synthesize "best of" lists, often excluding brands that lack structured authority signals. A 2025 study published in PNAS reveals an "AI-AI bias," where models prefer AI-optimized content over human-centric content by up to 78%, meaning brands that fail to structure data for AI consumption are systematically deprioritized. Marketers must shift focus from ranking for keywords to winning the specific "Us vs. Them" evaluation logic of the model.

Key Risks in AI Comparisons

• Omission: Being completely left out of "Top 5" lists.

• Hallucination: AI inventing non-existent flaws or pricing.

• False Equivalence: Being compared to irrelevant low-tier competitors.

---

The "Feature Moat" Strategy: Defining Your Lane

A Feature Moat is a unique, named attribute or proprietary methodology that forces AI models to categorize your brand as distinct from generic competitors. A 2024 study on LLM Brand Bias indicates that LLMs exhibit "brand bias," associating global brands with positive attributes while often downgrading local or generic brands. By anchoring your brand to specific, proprietary entities (e.g., "DECA's Multi-Agent Architecture"), you prevent direct, apples-to-apples comparisons with commodity players.

The Feature Moat Framework: From Generic Keywords to Branded Entities

AI models commoditize brands that rely on generic descriptors. To secure a high Share of Model, marketers must shift from descriptive keywords (which invite comparison) to proprietary entities (which demand definition). The table below illustrates how to rename core offerings to create a semantic barrier against direct competition.

Before (Generic Term)	After (Entity Moat)	AI Impact
"AI Content Writing"	"Generative Engine Optimization (GEO)"	Creates a new category
"SEO Tool"	"Entity-First Search Platform"	Changes comparison criteria
"Fast Processing"	"Hyper-Velocity Indexing Protocol"	Prevents direct speed comparison

Implementation Steps:

1. Audit: Identify generic terms in your copy (e.g., "AI writing tool").

2. Rename: Convert features into entities (e.g., "Generative Engine Optimization Platform").

3. Seed: Publish definition pages that link the new entity exclusively to your brand.

---

Optimizing for "Share of Model" (SoM)

Share of Model (SoM) is the percentage of times a brand is mentioned in AI-generated responses for category-level queries, serving as the modern equivalent of Share of Voice. With the global AI search market projected to reach $50.88 billion by 2033 (Grand View Research), tracking and optimizing SoM is essential for long-term visibility. High SoM correlates with being a "reference entity" in the model's Knowledge Graph.

The KPI Shift: From Traffic to Authority

Traditional SEO chases transient clicks. Defensive GEO builds permanent equity in the model's knowledge base. The table below outlines the fundamental shift in measurement.

Metric	Traditional SEO	Defensive GEO
Goal	Rank #1 on SERP	Be cited in the AI Answer
Measurement	Click-Through Rate (CTR)	Share of Model (SoM)
Tactic	Backlinks & Keywords	Entity Co-occurrence & Citations
Outcome	Traffic	Trust & Authority

---

Countering Negative Hallucinations with Data Seeding

Data Seeding is the proactive publication of structured "Fact Sheets" designed to ground LLMs and prevent the generation of inaccurate or negative comparative points. According to GreenBook, 62% of consumers report higher trust in brands that transparently disclose AI usage and data sources. Providing clear, machine-readable correction data (e.g., pricing tables, feature lists) reduces the probability of AI "guessing" wrong information.

The "Truth File" Protocol:

• Create a /brand-facts page on your domain.

• Use simple HTML tables for Price, Features, and Integrations.

• Update quarterly to signal freshness to crawling bots.

---

Building AI-Resilient Brand Authority

Defensive GEO is not just about avoiding bad press; it is about engineering your brand's digital DNA so that AI models recognize it as the canonical source of truth. As "AI-AI bias" grows, the brands that speak the language of LLMs—structured, factual, and entity-rich—will dominate the answers of the future. Start by auditing your current "Share of Model" and establishing your Feature Moats today.

---

FAQs

What is the difference between Defensive GEO and Reputation Management?

Defensive GEO focuses specifically on influencing Generative AI outputs and Knowledge Graphs. While traditional reputation management targets human sentiment on review sites, Defensive GEO targets the training data and retrieval logic of LLMs to prevent hallucinations.

How can we fix inaccurate AI answers about our brand?

Correction requires publishing conflicting, authoritative data on high-trust domains. You cannot "edit" ChatGPT, but you can "flood" the retrieval context with correct information formatted as structured data (Schema markup, tables) on your official site and Tier 1 publications.

What is the step-by-step process for correcting AI hallucinations?

The "Displace and Replace" protocol involves identifying the error, creating a "Truth File" with correct data, and syndicating it across high-authority sources. This forces RAG (Retrieval-Augmented Generation) systems to retrieve the new, structured facts over old data.

What are the legal risks of ignoring AI brand defense?

Ignoring AI outputs can lead to uncontested trademark dilution and liability for hallucinated advice attributed to your brand. According to legal experts, "failure to correct known misinformation" may become a liability standard for corporate negligence.

Does Defensive GEO require technical coding skills?

No, but it requires structured writing discipline. While Schema markup helps, the core of Defensive GEO is writing clear, logical content (A-E-I framework) that machines can easily parse, understand, and cite without ambiguity.

---

Reference

• Concord | https://www.concordusa.com/blog/the-evolution-of-search-in-2025-what-ai-means-for-seo

• PNAS | https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2415697122

• A 2024 study on LLM Brand Bias (arXiv) | https://arxiv.org/html/2406.13997v1

• Grand View Research | https://www.grandviewresearch.com/industry-analysis/ai-search-engine-market-report

• GreenBook | https://www.greenbook.org/insights/artificial-intelligence-and-machine-learning/ai-and-brand-trust-the-tipping-point-is-now