The New Scorecard: Measuring Success in the GEO Era
Introduction: The Death of "Rank #1"
For 20 years, the SEO industry has worshipped a single god: Rankings. Clients asked, "Are we number one for 'best CRM'?" and agencies pointed to a blue link on Google.
But in the age of Generative Engine Optimization (GEO), rankings are a relic. When ChatGPT or Gemini gives a user a single, synthesized answer, there is no "Page 2." There are no ten blue links. There is only The Answer.
If you are still reporting on keyword rankings and organic traffic, you are measuring the wrong thing. You are using a map of the old world to navigate the new one.
It’s time to tear up the old scorecard. Here is how we measure what actually matters: Visibility, Influence, and Sentiment in the AI Ecosystem.
1. The Vanity Metrics vs. The Sanity Metrics
Traditional SEO metrics are becoming "Vanity Metrics"—they look good on paper but don't reflect reality. GEO introduces "Sanity Metrics" that prove you are part of the conversation.
Keyword Rank
Search results are personalized and dynamic. "Rank" is fluid.
Share of Model (SoM)
How often does the AI mention your brand when asked relevant questions?
Organic Traffic
AI provides answers on the platform (Zero-Click). Users don't click through.
Citation Authority
Is your content used as the source of the AI's truth?
Click-Through Rate (CTR)
Irrelevant if the user gets the answer without clicking.
Sentiment Score
When the AI mentions you, is it positive ("Highly recommended") or neutral?
2. The Core GEO Metrics Explained
A. Share of Model (SoM)
Think of this as "Share of Voice" for AI.
The Question: "If I ask ChatGPT 'What is the best accounting software for small business?', does it mention my brand?"
The Goal: To be included in the "Consideration Set" generated by the LLM.
Measurement: We test a set of 50 transactional prompts and calculate the percentage of times your brand appears in the output.
B. Citation Frequency
The Question: "Is the AI reading my content?"
The Goal: To have your whitepapers, blogs, and case studies linked as footnotes or sources in Perplexity, Bing Chat, and SGE.
The Value: A citation is the new backlink. It signals to the user (and the engine) that you are the authority.
C. Sentiment Analysis
The Question: "How does the AI describe me?"
The Goal: To shift the narrative from "Brand X is an option" to "Brand X is the industry leader for enterprise solutions."
Measurement: Analyzing the adjectives and context used around your brand name in AI outputs.
3. The New Reporting Dashboard
Stop sending clients 50-page PDFs of keyword rankings. Send them a GEO Impact Report.
Section 1: The Visibility Snapshot
"Out of 100 queries related to 'Enterprise Security', your brand appeared in 68 AI responses (68% SoM)."
Section 2: The Citation Defense
"Your '2024 Security Trends Report' was cited as a primary source by Perplexity AI 15 times this month."
Section 3: The Sentiment Shift
"Last month, Gemini described your pricing as 'expensive'. After our 'Value Proposition' content campaign, it now describes your pricing as 'premium but high-ROI'."
Conclusion: Measure Influence, Not Just Traffic
The goal of GEO is not just to drive traffic to your site; it is to influence the answer wherever the user asks the question.
If a user asks an AI for a recommendation and the AI says, "I recommend [Your Brand] because they have the most reliable data," you have won. Even if they never visit your website.
Don't count clicks. Count conversations.
FAQ
Q: Can we track SoM automatically? A: Yes. We use custom scripts and tools to query LLMs (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity) with your target keywords and log the presence of your brand in the responses.
Q: Does traffic still matter? A: Yes, but its role has changed. Traffic is now for conversion (people who are ready to buy), while AI visibility is for brand awareness and consideration.
Q: How long does it take to improve Sentiment? A: It typically takes 3-6 months of consistent, high-E-E-A-T content publication for LLMs to update their internal associations with your brand.
Last updated