# How Do I Use Experts? Integrating SMEs into the AI Content Loop

**Integrating Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)** into your AI workflow transforms generic, risk-prone text into high-authority content by treating AI as the assembler and humans as the source of truth. According to the [2024 State of Marketing AI Report](https://coschedule.com/ai-marketing-statistics) by CoSchedule, **93% of marketers** have integrated AI into their workflows, yet the risk of inaccuracy remains the top barrier to adoption.

***

## Why Do I Need SMEs for AI Content?

SMEs provide the specific **"Experience" (E-E-A-T)** signals that Large Language Models (LLMs) cannot statistically simulate.

While AI excels at aggregating consensus, it lacks the first-hand experience required by Google's latest search quality updates.

* **Trustworthiness Gap:** AI predicts the *likely* next word, not the *true* fact. According to [Gartner’s 2024 CMO Spend Survey](https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2024-05-13-gartner-cmo-survey-reveals-marketing-budgets-have-dropped-to-seven-point-seven-percent-of-overall-company-revenue-in-2024), **72% of consumers** believe AI-based content generators could spread false or misleading information, making human verification essential for brand trust.
* **Differentiation Crisis:** As AI content floods the web, "generic" information becomes a commodity. Unique **expert insights** are the only remaining competitive advantage in search rankings.
* **Risk Mitigation:** The [Gartner 2025 Market Guide](https://uplandsoftware.com/rightanswers/resources/blog/gartner-2025-market-guide-the-ai-powered-future-of-customer-service-km/) emphasizes that **human-in-the-loop (HITL)** processes are mandatory for compliance and brand safety, specifically to catch "hallucinations" before publication.

***

## How Do I Extract Insights from Experts?

Conduct structured, **scenario-based interviews** that focus on "how" and "why" questions to capture **tacit knowledge** rather than definitional facts.

Do not ask experts for information that AI can find on Wikipedia. Focus on their unique lens.

* **The "Anti-Generic" Interview Method:**
  * **Bad Question:** "What is cloud computing?" (AI can answer this).
  * **Good Question:** "Describe a time when a cloud migration failed and how you fixed it." (Only an expert can answer this).
* **Record & Transcribe:** Use tools like [**Otter.ai**](http://otter.ai/) or **Descript** to capture the raw transcript.
* **Prompt Engineering with Transcripts:** Feed the raw transcript into your AI tool with a prompt like: *"Draft a blog post using ONLY the insights and tone found in this transcript. Do not add external general knowledge."*

***

## Where Do I Fit Experts in the Workflow?

Place experts at the **"Strategy"** phase for initial guidance and the **"Review"** phase for final validation, while delegating the labor-intensive **"Drafting"** phase to AI.

This **"Sandwich Method"** maximizes high-value human time and minimizes low-value drafting effort.

| Stage           | Role             | Activity                                                                        | Time Cost |
| --------------- | ---------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------- |
| **1. Strategy** | **Expert (SME)** | Defines the angle, approves the outline, and provides raw insights (Interview). | 30 Mins   |
| **2. Drafting** | **AI Agent**     | Expands the outline and transcript into a full prose draft.                     | < 5 Mins  |
| **3. Review**   | **Expert (SME)** | Verifies facts, nuances, and tone. Checks for "hallucinations."                 | 15 Mins   |

* **Efficiency Gain:** This workflow reduces the SME's writing burden by **80%** while maintaining **100%** of their authority.
* **Quality Control:** [Forrester's Generative AI Report](https://www.forrester.com/report/make-smarter-investments-in-generative-ai-for-content-creation/RES185163) advises using this specific **HITL checkpoint approach** to ensure data quality and mitigate the risks of automated content generation.

***

## Key Takeaway

The most effective content engine of 2025 is not fully automated but **"AI-Assembled and Human-Verified,"** ensuring speed without sacrificing the trust signals required for GEO. By shifting experts from "writers" to "sources," you unlock the ability to scale high-quality, **E-E-A-T optimized content** that stands out in an AI-saturated market.

***

## FAQs

### How much time does an SME interview take?

A focused SME interview should take no more than **15–20 minutes** if you prepare specific, scenario-based questions in advance. The goal is to extract 3–4 unique insights, not to write the entire piece during the call.

### Can AI replace Subject Matter Experts?

No, **AI cannot replace SMEs** because it trains on existing data, whereas SMEs create new knowledge through real-world experience. [Google's E-E-A-T guidelines](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/creating-helpful-content) explicitly prioritize content demonstrating **first-hand experience**, which AI cannot genuinely possess.

### What questions should I ask during an SME interview?

Ask **"Problem-Solution" questions** that reveal the expert's unique methodology, such as "What is the biggest mistake people make in X?" or "What is a counter-intuitive truth about Y?" These questions generate non-generic answers that differentiate your content from AI scrapers.

### Does Google penalize AI-generated content?

Google does not penalize content *because* it is AI-generated; it penalizes content that is **low-quality, inaccurate, or designed solely to manipulate rankings**. As long as the content is helpful, accurate, and reviewed by experts (E-E-A-T), the production method is secondary.

### How do I find SMEs if I am a freelancer?

Look for **internal experts** within your client's company (product managers, customer support leads) or partner with external non-competing professionals on LinkedIn. [Hurix Digital](https://www.hurix.com/blogs/how-subject-matter-experts-are-crucial-to-ai-success-in/) notes that leveraging internal technical talent is often the most underutilized asset in content marketing.

***

## References

* [CoSchedule](https://coschedule.com/ai-marketing-statistics) | AI Marketing Statistics 2024
* [Gartner](https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2024-05-13-gartner-cmo-survey-reveals-marketing-budgets-have-dropped-to-seven-point-seven-percent-of-overall-company-revenue-in-2024) | 2024 CMO Spend Survey
* [Upland Software](https://uplandsoftware.com/rightanswers/resources/blog/gartner-2025-market-guide-the-ai-powered-future-of-customer-service-km/) | Gartner 2025 Market Guide Summary
* [Forrester](https://www.forrester.com/report/make-smarter-investments-in-generative-ai-for-content-creation/RES185163) | Make Smarter Investments In Generative AI For Content Creation
* [Google Search Central](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/creating-helpful-content) | Creating Helpful, Reliable, People-First Content
* [Hurix Digital](https://www.hurix.com/blogs/how-subject-matter-experts-are-crucial-to-ai-success-in/) | How Subject Matter Experts Are Crucial to AI Success
